Why I finally stopped treating my email list like a junk drawer
Lesson learned: Sending to more people is not the same as reaching more people. If your list quality slides, your deliverability slides with it.
The pain point that forced the issue- Open rates drifting down even though offers and subject lines were not worse
- More “undeliverable” replies and a slow drip of complaints
- A nagging sense that I was paying (and working) to email people who were never going to see it
What was really happening (and why it matters)- Deliverability is reputation. Mailbox providers watch how recipients react to your mail. If many messages bounce, get ignored, or get flagged, future messages are more likely to land in spam or promotions.
- Bounces are not just “errors.” A high bounce rate is a signal that you are not maintaining your list. Repeatedly mailing dead addresses looks like sloppy hygiene at best and spammy behavior at worst.
- List rot is normal. People change jobs, abandon side projects, and retire old inboxes. Even a careful list decays over time, especially B2B lists.
- “More subscribers” can hide lower revenue. If your audience is 20% unreachable, your reporting gets fuzzy: you might think a campaign underperformed when it actually never had a chance to reach people.
The workflow I use now (simple, repeatable, and boring)- Frequency: once per month if you mail weekly, otherwise once per quarter
- Goal: remove obvious bad addresses before sending, then suppress addresses that bounce after sending
- Principle: keep changes auditable - do not delete first, suppress first
Step 1 - Make your list a “master” plus “segments”- Master list: everyone who has permission to receive email (the source of truth)
- Suppression list: addresses you do not send to (hard bounces, unsubscribes, repeated soft bounces, role accounts if you choose)
- Segments: groups you mail for specific campaigns (customers, leads, webinar attendees, etc.)
Why this structure works- It prevents accidental resends to bad addresses. If suppression is its own list, you can apply it to every send.
- It keeps your history. Deleting throws away information you may need later (why did someone stop receiving mail?).
- It makes you calmer. You can be aggressive about suppressing without fear of losing data forever.
Step 2 - Preflight: verify addresses before a big send- When I do it: before any major campaign (product launch, seasonal sale) or if the list changed a lot since last time
- What I check: syntax, domain validity, and mailbox-level signals where possible
A practical tool fit (when it actually helps)- If you manage lists locally and want a dedicated preflight step, eMail Verifier is useful for running a verification pass and exporting results you can merge back into your master list.
- I am not trying to “prove” an address is perfect forever. I am trying to catch obvious failures before I send and damage reputation.
How I interpret verification results (opinionated, but earned)- Invalid / non-existent: suppress immediately. Do not “try it anyway.”
- Disposable or temporary domains: depends on your business. For B2B, I usually suppress. For consumer lists, I may keep but watch engagement.
- Catch-all domains: I keep them, but I watch bounces closely. Catch-all is not bad; it just reduces certainty.
- Role addresses (info@, sales@): I usually suppress unless the person explicitly requested mail from that address. These accounts often forward to multiple people and generate more complaints.
Step 3 - Send with a consistent “identity” and sane cadence- Same From name and domain: reputation attaches to patterns. Constantly changing identity looks like hiding.
- Predictable cadence: sporadic bursts train recipients to forget you. Forgetting is how you get marked as spam later.
- Mail fewer people, better. I would rather send to 3,000 reachable humans than 10,000 addresses with a big dead zone.
Why cadence affects list hygiene- If you email once every six months, many people will not remember opting in. That increases complaints even if you are “technically allowed” to email them.
- Consistent mail gives you engagement data you can trust. Engagement makes it easier to decide who to keep, who to reconfirm, and who to suppress.
Step 4 - Postflight: process bounces and update suppression- Hard bounces: suppress immediately (invalid mailbox, no such user, domain does not exist)
- Soft bounces: I give them 2-3 attempts over 30 days, then suppress if it persists (mailbox full, temporary failure)
- Complaints: suppress immediately, no debate
Where a bounce tool earns its keep- If you receive bounce messages back to a mailbox and want to process them systematically, eMail Bounce Handler is built for turning that messy inbox into a clean list of what to suppress.
- The value is not “automation for automation’s sake.” The value is consistency. You stop letting bounces pile up.
Step 5 - Keep acquisition clean (or cleanup becomes endless)- Double opt-in: I use it for most forms. It cuts spam signups and typos. Yes, it reduces raw signups. That is fine.
- Make typos obvious: show the email back to the user and ask them to confirm it before submission.
- Do not buy lists. Even if it “works once,” you will spend months paying the reputation penalty.
A note on extracting emails (and why I mostly avoid it)- Tools like eMail Extractor can be appropriate when you are extracting your own contacts from documents or archives for housekeeping, consolidation, or migration.
- I do not use extraction for prospecting strangers. The ethical issue matters, but the practical one is simpler: cold scraped lists tend to bounce and complain more, which damages deliverability for everything else you send.
My “boring” monthly cleanup routine (the one that sticks)
1) Export the current master list.
2) Run a verification pass on addresses added since last cleanup.
3) Suppress clear invalids before the next send.
4) After sending, process bounces.
5) Update suppression (hard bounces immediately).
6) Tag soft bounces and suppress if repeated.
7) Log counts so I can see trends over time.
The tiny bit of logging that changed my decisions- New addresses added: count per month
- Invalid at verification: percent of new adds (if this rises, your forms or sources are getting messy)
- Hard bounce rate: per campaign
- Complaint count: per campaign
- Suppressed total: running number (it should slowly grow - that is normal)
Why tracking trends works better than obsessing over a single send- One campaign can have a weird spike due to a temporary issue (recipient server outage, a single bad segment import).
- Trends tell you whether the system is healthy. A steady increase in invalid new addresses usually points to a specific acquisition source or form problem.
Common mistakes I made (so you do not have to)- Waiting until deliverability is obviously bad. By the time you notice, you have likely trained filters to distrust you.
- Deleting instead of suppressing. Deleting feels decisive, but you lose context and you risk re-importing the same bad address later.
- Keeping “maybe bad” addresses forever. Soft bounces that never resolve are just slow-motion hard bounces.
- Measuring success by list size. List size is a vanity metric if your messages do not land in inboxes.
Where MaxBulk Mailer fits (if you run your own list workflow)- If you prefer managing mailings locally and want practical list handling, segmentation, and sending in a desktop tool, MaxBulk Mailer can sit nicely in this workflow.
- The key is not the tool - it is the discipline: apply suppression every time and treat cleanup as routine maintenance.
One internal reference (for context)Checklist- Maintain a master list and a separate suppression list
- Verify new addresses before major sends
- Suppress invalids immediately and track soft bounces
- Process bounces after every campaign, not “when you have time”
- Use double opt-in (or an equivalent confirmation step) for most signup sources
- Log a few simple counts monthly to spot trend problems early
Exactly 3 Actionable Takeaways- Create a suppression list today and apply it to every send before you touch subject lines or templates.
- Pick a recurring calendar date for cleanup and treat it like bookkeeping - routine maintenance, not a special project.
- Decide in writing how you handle hard bounces, soft bounces, and role addresses - then follow it consistently.
Recent questions from our MaxBulk Mailer users |
|
|
|
|
